In Re Vijayneha Polymers Private Limited (GST AAR Telangana)
Author: Gulzar Hashmi • Publish Date:
PRIMARY_KEYWORDS: ITC on machine foundation; plant and machinery; Section 17(5) CGST | SECONDARY_KEYWORDS: works contract; factory building; AAR Telangana; GST input credit
Slug: in-re-vijayneha-polymers-private-limited-gst-aar-telangana
Quick Summary
The AAR Telangana held that input tax credit (ITC) is available on works contract services to the extent of machine foundation. The foundation is part of plant and machinery used for business, so the ITC block in Section 17(5) does not apply to that portion.
Issues
- Can the applicant claim ITC on GST charged by works contractors for machine foundation?
- Is machine foundation covered as part of plant and machinery for Section 17(5) purposes?
Rules
- Section 17(5), CGST Act — Restricts ITC on certain works contracts relating to immovable property; but does not block ITC for plant and machinery (including foundation and structural support).
- Definition of Plant & Machinery — Includes foundation and structural supports used for installation of apparatus/equipment used for business.
Facts (Timeline)
Arguments
Applicant
- Machine foundation is integral to operating the plant.
- Falls within plant & machinery including foundation/supports.
- Therefore, ITC on that portion should be allowed.
Revenue Perspective
- Works contract for immovable property generally blocked under Section 17(5).
- Need to verify the extent that relates to plant & machinery vs civil construction.
Judgment
The AAR held that the applicant is entitled to ITC on GST charged by works contractors to the extent of the machine foundation. Since foundation forms part of plant & machinery, the Section 17(5) restriction does not apply to that specific portion.
Ratio
Foundation = Plant & Machinery: Where works contract costs relate to foundation/structural support of machinery used in business, ITC is allowed for that part.
Why It Matters
- Gives capital project clarity on ITC split between civil works and machinery.
- Helps manufacturers plan cost allocation and documentation.
- Exam tip: apply the plant & machinery carve-out under Section 17(5).
Key Takeaways
ITC allowed on machine foundation.
Section 17(5) carve-out for plant & machinery.
Keep evidence to prove allocation.
Civil works ITC may still be blocked.
Mnemonic + 3-Step Hook
Mnemonic: “Fix the Base, Claim the Credit.”
- Fix — Is it foundation/support for machinery?
- Base — Falls inside plant & machinery definition.
- Credit — ITC allowed for that portion under Section 17(5).
IRAC Outline
Issue
Is ITC available on works contract services for machine foundation?
Rule
Section 17(5) blocks civil construction ITC but excludes plant & machinery (incl. foundation/support).
Application
Foundation supports machines used for production; hence within the exclusion.
Conclusion
ITC allowed to the extent of machine foundation.
Glossary
- ITC (Input Tax Credit)
- Credit of GST paid on inputs/input services used in the course of business.
- Works Contract
- Composite supply for building/construction/installation jobs involving goods and services.
- Plant & Machinery
- Includes foundation/structural support for machines used for business operations.
FAQs
Related Cases
- AAR/AAAR rulings on Section 17(5) and plant & machinery scope.
- Decisions distinguishing civil works vs equipment installation credits.
- Advance rulings on manufacturing setup ITC allocation.
Share
Tags
Archive
Popular & Recent Post
Comment
Nothing for now