• Today: September 11, 2025

Agreement under the Indian Contract Act, 1872

11 September, 2025
10484

Agreement under the Indian Contract Act, 1872

The definition of an agreement is outlined in section 2(e) of the Indian Contract Act, 1872. An agreement is a promise or set of promises made between two parties, with consideration involved. For instance, in a rent agreement, both parties (the owner and the tenant) participate, and the consideration is usually in the form of money, such as rent.

Key Aspects Necessary for an Agreement

  • Parties: There must be a minimum of two parties involved in an agreement, though more than two parties can also be involved depending on the circumstances.
  • Offer: An offer must be made by one party to another, and this offer should be specified in the agreement.
  • Acceptance: The other party must accept the offer. Acceptance is crucial for an agreement, and it must be given willingly by the accepting party.
  • Promises: Both parties must promise to fulfill the duties and obligations outlined in the agreement.
  • Consideration: Consideration refers to the value exchanged, such as money or another benefit, for fulfilling the promises made.

Conditions That Render Agreements Void

  • No Consideration: If there is no consideration, meaning no value is exchanged between the parties, the agreement is not valid.
  • Agreement in Restraint of Trade: If one party restricts the other from engaging in trade, business, or any livelihood, the agreement is void.
  • Agreement to Restrain Marriage: If one party restricts another from marrying, promising a gift or reward for not marrying, the agreement is invalid.
  • Agreement to Restrain Legal Proceedings: If a contract prevents one party from pursuing legal action, it is considered null and void.
  • Impossible Acts: If the agreement involves performing an act that is impossible, it is void.

All these conditions must be satisfied for an agreement to be valid. If any of these conditions are present and are considered illegal under the Indian Contract Act, the agreement is deemed void.

Section 3 of the Indian Contract Act 1872 - Communication of the Proposal

Communication is crucial in maintaining both legal and personal relationships. Communication of a proposal means that all terms and conditions must be clearly conveyed to the other party to ensure mutual understanding. Communication can be either implied or expressed. Expressed communication involves clearly stating terms, either verbally or in writing. Implied communication means understanding the terms or conditions without them being explicitly stated; there is no direct exchange of words.

Essential Requirements for a Valid Agreement Under This Section

  • Communication of Agreement: The agreement must be communicated to both parties, either impliedly or expressly. Without proper communication, there can be misunderstandings, leading to confusion and differing interpretations.
  • Proposal Must Contain a Promise: The proposal should include a promise. Without a promise, there is no agreement, and the agreement is considered void and null.
  • Validity and Certainty of Proposal: The proposal must be valid and certain, meaning that the conditions mentioned in the contract or agreement must be feasible. Immaterial or impossible conditions should not be included.
  • Intention in the Proposal: The proposal should clearly express the intention of the promiser and the promisee to avoid misunderstandings.
  • Avoidance of Negative Statements: The proposal should not contain any negative statements, as these can create a negative impression and potentially harm the relationship between the parties.
  • Clarity of Terms and Conditions: The proposal should include all terms and conditions clearly and understandably, without ambiguity.
  • Truthfulness and Absence of Fraud: The proposal must be free from any false statements or fraudulent elements.

Section 4 of the Indian Contract Act

Section 4 states that communication is considered complete when it reaches the person to whom it is made. Communication of an offer is accepted when the person receiving it accepts the contract or proposal, signifying that the communication has been accepted.

Section 5 of the Indian Contract Act - Revocation of the Proposal and Acceptance

A proposal can be revoked before the communication of its acceptance by the promisee. For example, if person X offers to sell his watch to person Y, X can revoke the offer before Y accepts it. The proposal can be revoked at any time before the acceptance is communicated.

Section 6 of the Indian Contract Act – Revocation How Made

  • Through Notice: The proposal can be revoked by communicating the notice of revocation to the other party.
  • By Lapse of Time: If the offeree does not accept the offer within the prescribed time, or if no time is prescribed, within a reasonable time, the offer can be revoked.
  • Failure of Condition Precedent: If the offer was conditional and the condition is not met, the offer can be revoked.
  • Death of the Proposer: If the proposer dies before acceptance, and the acceptor is aware of the death, the offer can be revoked.

Section 7 of the Indian Contract Act – Acceptance Must Be Absolute

For a proposal to become a promise, the acceptance must be absolute and unqualified. Acceptance should be expressed clearly, and if a specific mode of acceptance is prescribed, the offeree must follow it. If the acceptance is not in the prescribed manner, the proposer can insist on the specified manner, or else the acceptance is considered valid.

Section 8 of the Indian Contract Act – Acceptance by Performing Conditions or Receiving Consideration

Acceptance can occur through performing the conditions of the offer or by receiving consideration. If the acceptor fulfills the conditions of the offer or accepts the consideration, it is considered acceptance of the proposal.

Section 9 of the Indian Contract Act – Promises, Express and Implied

This section differentiates between express and implied promises. An express promise is made through words or writing, while an implied promise is made through conduct or actions. For example, if person X parks his car and person Z starts cleaning it without any discussion, it is considered an implied offer by Z.

Case Study: Manglam Express Cargo Pvt. Ltd. v. Union Of India & Ors.

Manmohan, the petitioner, filed a writ petition challenging an order passed by the Divisional Railway Manager on October 28, 2015. This order terminated the petitioner's licensing contract, forfeited the profits earned, and banned the petitioner from participating in any activities under the railway department for two years. The critical fact in this case was that the petitioner had received acceptance from the other party (the respondent). The petitioner's counsel argued that the actions of the railway department were not legally sound. The court ordered the railway department (the respondent) to refund the money to the petitioner within six weeks from the date of the judgment. The case referred to Section 6(2) of the Indian Contract Act, 1872, which states that if the other party does not accept the offer within the prescribed time, the proposer may revoke the offer, or if no time is prescribed, within a reasonable time. Thus, there was no enforcement of the contract under the law.

Case Study: Rajlucky Dabee v. Bhootnath Mookerjee

Facts of the Case

  • There were quarrels and disagreements between the husband and wife.
  • The husband promised to pay a certain amount to his wife for maintenance to separate from her.
  • This agreement was registered, but later, the husband denied paying the amount, and the wife sued him for recovery.

Contention of the Parties

The wife argued that there was a written and registered contract, indicating an intention to sue, so she should receive the promised money.

Decision of the Court

The court observed that there was no love and affection between the parties, but there was a near relationship and a written and registered agreement. The court ruled that for such a contract to be valid, there must be consideration. Since the agreement was not made out of natural love and affection but was a transaction, it required consideration to be valid. As there was no consideration, the contract was deemed invalid, and the wife could not enforce the contract.

Comment

Nothing for now