Distributive Justice: Concept and Application in Various Legal Systems
1. Introduction
- Distributive justice addresses the ownership and fair allocation of goods and resources in society.
- It emphasizes collaboration and equitable distribution of resources for the "common good."
2. Meaning of Distributive Justice
- Fair allocation of common goods (e.g., income, education, healthcare) and burdens (e.g., taxes).
- Operates on principles of equity, equality, and social need.
- Resources are distributed for community welfare, guided by political institutions and legal frameworks.
3. Objective of Distributive Justice
- Ensures the common good by appropriately allocating roles and resources to individuals.
- Recognizes unique needs and contributions of members, promoting societal prosperity.
4. John Rawls and Distributive Justice
- Veil of Ignorance: Decisions are made without knowing one's societal status to ensure fairness.
- Difference Principle: Goods should be distributed equally unless inequalities benefit the least advantaged.
5. Distributive Justice in Various Legal Systems
5.1. In the Indian Context
- Reservation Policies:
- Aimed at uplifting marginalized communities, validated by the Supreme Court (e.g., Mandal Commission Report).
- Public Interest Litigation (PIL): Empowers citizens to seek judicial intervention for public welfare.
- Environmental Principles:
- Polluter Pays Principle: Ensures accountability for environmental damage.
- Public Trust Doctrine: Protects public resources for collective benefit.
- Case Law:
- Maneka Gandhi v. Union of India: Established "due process of law" ensuring fairness.
- A.K. Gopalan v. State of Madras: Broadened procedural rights to include justice.
5.2. In Other Legal Systems
- Progressive tax systems, inheritance laws, and welfare programs in countries like the USA and UK reflect distributive justice.
- International treaties address global inequalities (e.g., climate change and poverty alleviation).
6. Conclusion
- Promotes equity, equality, and social need for fairness in resource allocation and societal responsibilities.
- Addresses issues like poverty, education, and environmental sustainability.
- Forms the foundation for societal development and a balanced, prosperous society.
Corrective Justice: Concept and Analysis
1. Meaning of Corrective Justice
- Definition: Focuses on rectifying injustices caused by one party to another.
- Aristotle’s View:
- Explained in Nicomachean Ethics, corrective justice rectifies injustices in voluntary (contracts) or involuntary (torts) interactions.
2. Analysis of the Concept of Corrective Justice
- Rectification Process:
- Addresses both the wrongful gain of the defendant and the wrongful loss of the plaintiff.
- Justice is achieved when the defendant surrenders the gain, and the plaintiff is compensated for the loss.
- Correlativity Principle:
- The injustice connects the plaintiff (victim) and defendant (wrongdoer).
- The law reverses this injustice through remedies.
- Comparison with Distributive Justice:
- Corrective Justice: Focuses on two parties and corrects specific injustices.
- Distributive Justice: Involves resource distribution among multiple parties for societal fairness.
- J.Burnet’s Critique:
- Justice operates differently in voluntary and involuntary interactions:
- Voluntary: Ensures fair exchange.
- Involuntary: Determines punishment proportional to harm caused.
- Justice operates differently in voluntary and involuntary interactions:
3. Tort Law as Corrective Justice
- Relation to Corrective Justice: Tort law addresses harm caused by one party to another, requiring compensation.
- Aristotle’s Influence: Balances wrongful gains and losses in tort cases.
- Key Features:
- Local Scope: Tort cases focus on specific events.
- Justice Intuition: Remedies satisfy the innate sense of justice.
- Practical Application: Maintains fairness in legal transactions and remedies individual harms.
4. Conclusion
- Purpose: Restores balance by addressing wrongful actions.
- Legal Framework: Explains liability and remedies for resolving conflicts.
- Significance:
- Serves as a foundation for tort law and individual dispute resolution.
- Provides a coherent framework for rectifying harm and maintaining societal balance.
Popular & Recent Post
Comment
Nothing for now